Baseball section! Do you agree with this?

Ok so im watching MLBN and Eric Byrnes just said something i found interesting. In the Mariners/As game there was just a triple play, and the reply showed that Ellis was safe at first. What Eric said was that umpires should make those calls just to reserve the great feat. Meaning, whether Ellis was safe or out, the umpire should call him out because its for the triple play. Or, for Galarraga's perfect game, whether the last play is out or safe, if its close they should just call him out regardless. Do you agree with this idea? that umpires should make calls to preserve great things? or should they make the RIGHT call regardless of the situation?